Oppose Book Bans, Read Trans Historical Fiction

4 hours ago 2

Rommie Analytics

Queer historical fiction is near and dear to my heart. I started writing about—and reading—a lot more historical fiction when I saw how it could be used to reveal aspects of history that are ignored or forgotten. Stories of queer people throughout history are a form of past and present protest and determination; they say we are here, we’ve always been here, and we’ll always be here. That continues to be important in a time when the United States government takes part in increasing attacks on LGBTQ, and especially trans, people in this country. We’re talking about a government that forced the National Parks Service to erase all mentions of transgender people from a webpage about the 1969 Stonewall Rebellion in New York City, a movement that was literally led by trans women like Marsha P. Johnson.

We’re talking about a country where the state of Kansas recently revoked the driver’s licenses and birth certificates of 1,700 residents who updated their gender markers. A number of states, including Florida, Indiana, Kansas, Tennessee, and Texas, do not allow for the updating of gender markers on driver’s licenses, but the Kansas law goes one step further to invalidate licenses that have already been issued. Human Rights Watch points out that, in addition to the very real risk of discrimination and violence that this brings with it (something transgender people already face at alarming levels), it could also threaten their ability to travel or vote.

In addition to these very real and very discriminatory actions against transgender people, book bans continue to target books by and about LGBTQ and BIPOC people in disproportionate proportions. That’s an open secret at this point. In a move that likely surprises no one who’s been paying attention, House Republicans have now moved to advance a bill, House Resolution 7661 (H.R. 7661) or “Stop the Sexualization of Children Act,” that would prohibit the use of funds for anything deemed “sexually oriented material.” Just in case you couldn’t read between the lines there, they go ahead and spell it out in clear detail, defining “sexually oriented material” as anything discussing “gender dysphoria or transgenderism.” Kelly Jensen, who does incredible work reporting on book bans in the United States, says it best when explaining why these bans are about more than just books or freedom of speech:

“These bills aren’t about removing books; books are just one of the tools. These bills are about the complete and total erasure and removal of queer people from American life.”

I hope one day I’ll be able to write something like this without the need for a political primer in the introduction, but unfortunately the state of America is such that you can’t really write about books without writing about politics at the moment. I also hope that one day reading queer and trans books won’t be an act some people view as inherently political. The only way we get there, though, is by continuing to normalize reading the very books they want to ban. Trans historical fiction is inherently important. It’s a window into the past and a lifeline in the present. Trans books will always have a place in my heart and on my bookshelves. The people who try to erase them do not.

How Much of These Hills is Gold book cover

How Much of These Hills is Gold by C Pam Zhang

This novel is a Western like you’ve never read before. Newly orphaned children of immigrants, Lucy and Sam, set off into the wilderness to bury their Ba. But neither can agree on exactly what sort of resting place he deserves. The spirit of their father, meanwhile, watches on as his children struggle and remembers the hopes and misfortunes that brought them here. It’s a powerful story of family, identity, and belonging.

Cover Image of A Lady for All Seasons by TJ Alexander

A Lady for All Seasons by TJ Alexander

This companion novel to Alexander’s trans historical romance, A Gentleman’s Gentleman, follows a notorious society gossip finally forced to look for a marriage match. Verbena has already decided upon a suitor for herself before the season begins: her friend, the French tailor, Étienne. Their engagement—and eventual marriage—of convenience will provide Verbena the stability she needs and protect her friend from dangerous gossip about his sexuality. Then she meets William Forsythe, a writer, who, if not quite a respectable match, is certainly a more appealing one. That’s on top of the burgeoning feelings she already harbors for her new lady-poet friend, Flora. If only she hadn’t promised herself to Étienne. But what Verbena doesn’t know is that William and Flora are one and the same, two aspects of the same person who has fallen equally hard for Verbena.

It’s a comedy of manners and errors as Verbena, Flora, William Forsyth, Étienne (and his own suitor) attempt to find the love and lives they want for themselves.

cover of Bad Habit by Alana S. Portero, translated by Mara Faye Lethem

Bad Habit by Alana S. Portero, translated by Mara Faye Lethem

In 1980s and ’90s Madrid, amidst a heroin epidemic that ravaged the city and a renowned party scene, the unnamed protagonist of Portero’s novel leaves behind a working class neighborhood that has no place for her for the vibrant downtown nightlife scene. Amid the glittering parties of Madrid nightlife, she finally begins to find community. But even here, in a place beginning to feel like home, there are acts of violence she doesn’t know how to handle, and every decision can become life or death in an instant.

Small Beauty book cover

Small Beauty by jia qing wilson-yang

The nonlinear narrative of Small Beauty weaves together present and past as Mei, a trans Chinese-Canadian woman, moves from the city to a small town to mourn the death of her cousin. There, she reminisces about the trans women she left behind, learns long-buried secrets about her family, uncovers local mysteries, and receives advice from departed loved ones. While the setting is relatively contemporary, it involves frequent forays into Mei’s past.

cover of all the white spaces by ally wilkes

All the White Spaces by Ally Wilkes

Stowing away on an Antarctic expedition in the wake of the First World War is Jonathan Morgan’s chance to finally live as himself in the world of men. But not all is well. The horrors of the war still hang over them and the frozen sea is unforgiving. When they’re forced to abandon the ship and overwinter on land, it soon becomes clear that something is wrong within this barren landscape. Jonathan and the rest of the crew are alone out here with no hope of rescue. No one is coming, but something has been waiting for them among the ice nonetheless.

The Thirty Names of Night by Zeyn Joukhadar book cover

The Thirty Names of Night by Zeyn Joukhadar

A closeted young trans boy discovers the journal of a Syrian American artist who disappeared 60 years ago in the wake of his mother’s death. The artist, Laila Z, saw the same mysterious bird his mother had seen right before she died. Not only are the stories of Laila and his mother intimately connected, her journal also reveals the stories of queer and trans people from his own community—people he hadn’t realized existed before now. Finally emboldened to take on a new name, Nadir gathers friends and family to help him uncover the mystery of the bird his mother died trying to protect.

Lote book cover

Lote by Shola von Reinhold

Although set in the present, this book is transfixed with the past in a way that reads very “historical.” The protagonist of Lote, Mathilda, is obsessed with the literary and artistic circles of the Bright Young Things and the Bloomsbury Group of the 1920 and ’30s, but when a photograph introduces her to a Black modernist poet, Hermia Druitt, who seems to have run in their circles, she is determined to learn more and pull her out of obscurity. Her search takes her to a strange artist’s commune where Hermia supposedly lived for a time, where Mathilda falls even deeper into her obsession and begins to question everything about what we hold as “truth.”

Also keep an eye out for Gabe Cole Novoa’s reimagining of Persuasion, Rational Creatures, coming out later this year. His trans Pride and Prejudice retelling is one of my all-time favorite Austen retellings, so I can’t wait to see how he tackles Persuasion.

In the meantime, here are some more trans and LGBTQ+ book recs for you:

Must-Read LGBTQ+ Historical Fiction 8 Books to Read for Transgender History Month Trans Historical Fiction Books New Trans Historical Fiction For the Trans Rights Readathon
Read Entire Article