Yankees Fans Turn Down Juan Soto Peace Offering With Clear Message During Mets’ First Bronx Return

The first night of the Subway Series unfolded much as anticipated. Juan Soto drew a chorus of boos from the crowd, with fans eagerly turning their attention to every move he made. So, it was a familiar script in this intense New York rivalry. Yet, in a surprising twist, the game ended without a single home run from either side.

Now that’s a rarity in a matchup known for its power displays.

While it was expected that Soto will garner enough boos from the Yankee Stadium, the message conveyed by the crowd came out of nowhere. This time, it is quite unique for Soto as well.

“Bellinger flies out to deep right. Soto flips the ball into the crowd. They throw it back,” MLB insider, Bryan Hoch, shared in the middle of the game.

Bellinger flies out to deep right. Soto flips the ball into the crowd. They throw it back.

NYY 6, NYM 1, top 9

— Bryan Hoch (@BryanHoch) May 17, 2025

Fans took it a step further than just vocal jeers. It was in the ninth inning when Soto caught Bellinger’s hit and threw the ball toward the crowd. The Yankees faithful didn’t even bother keeping it. They immediately threw it right back to him. Well, it wasn’t just a missed souvenir, but a clear message.

The Bleacher Creatures made it unmistakably clear they weren’t interested in giving Soto any favors, sending a strong signal of their hostility throughout the game. So, no peace as of now!

It is quite surprising, considering baseball fans love collecting balls. Be it a foul ball, a home run, or a souvenir tossed by a player, they usually cherish the moment and keep the ball as a prized memory. And well, players often throw balls into the crowd as a gesture of fan appreciation, a way to connect and make them happy.

Soto might just have offered an olive branch here, but hey, when you are in Yankee Stadium, expect no friendliness! Especially if they are heartbroken and mad at you for leaving!

Well, from the game POV, there is nothing to boast about. Apart from Soto, taking names like Aaron Judge and Francisco Lindor, a homer seemed like an uphill task for them. Yes, the game went in the Yankees’ favor by 6-2, but it just made the next game more interesting.

Soto got what he was expected to receive. Maybe now, it is his turn to give it back!

How do you think Soto will make a mark in the next game? Keep an eye on this space to know more about the probabilities..

The post Yankees Fans Turn Down Juan Soto Peace Offering With Clear Message During Mets’ First Bronx Return appeared first on EssentiallySports.