The Most Read Books on Goodreads in May 2025

1 day ago 2

Rommie Analytics

The most read books on Goodreads in May has some overlap with April, but there are also a couple new titles—though they’re both by authors you’ll be very familiar with if you keep up with popular books. May was a little less romantasy-heavy than April: is that a sign of things or come, or just a temporary blip? Only time will tell.

The Empyrean series only has one book in the top five this time, with Fourth Wing dropping from #5 to #9. Romantasy sequel Fearless similarly slipped from #4 to #6. Replacing them are the newest releases from two bestselling authors: Freida McFadden’s The Tenant and Emily Henry’s Great Big Beautiful Life.

Before we get into the full list, let’s talk about a couple of May new releases worth highlighting.

Two New Books Out in May You Should Know About

Unfortunately, the most read books on Goodreads tend not to be diverse by any definition of the word. So, here are a couple of new books that came out in May that deserve wider readership.

cover of Old School Indian by Aaron John Curtis

Old School Indian by Aaron John Curtis

You’ve seen many coming-of-age novels by now, I’m sure, but have you ever seen a coming-of-middle-age one? In Curtis’s debut, Abe Jacobs is a 43-year-old Ahkwesáhsne man who begrudgingly returns to the reservation where he grew up after more than 20 years. The reason for his return? Doctors have told him he’s dying, and he’s decided on the way treatment he never thought he would: a healing at the hands of his unceremonious, recovered alcoholic great uncle Budge. Now, he remains skeptical of being healed, but in his exploring it, there’s a seed of hope. Through witty lines and the musings of Abe’s poet alter ego, Dominick Deer Woods, we see him confront all those things that kept him away from his home for all that time. —Erica Ezeifedi

cover of Kiss Me, Maybe by Gabriella Gamez

Kiss Me, Maybe by Gabriella Gamez

When The Next Best Fling came out last year I knew I was going to have a new favorite author, but that was sealed when I saw the cover for Kiss Me, Maybe. Not just for the cover (though I mean, LOOK at it!), but also because of the indication of who the next protagonist was going to be, and I was excited AF to read her love story. Asexual librarian Angela has never been kissed. When she posts something declaring so on social media, she accidentally goes viral, leading to a scavenger hunt that would lead to the winner getting her first kiss. And who’s there to help her out? Bartender Krystal, who Angela has had a longtime crush on. But she’s off limits and uninterested in love. Right? — Jessica Pryde

The Most Read Books on Goodreads in May 2025

#5:

cover of Onyx Storm by Rebecca Yarros; black and grey with gold detailing and white font and black dragon outline in center

Onyx Storm (The Empyrean #3) by Rebecca Yarros

Onyx Storm came out in January, but it has hung onto its spot in the top five most read books on Goodreads. This is book three in the romantasy series set at a dragon-riding academy. The newest Empyrean novel was read by more than 79,000 Goodreads users in May and has a 4.2 average rating.

#4:

Say You'll Remember Me cover

Say You’ll Remember Me by Abby Jimenez

This is the newest romance novel from the author of Just for the Summer. It follows Samantha, who has a perfect, endless date with handsome Greek veterinarian Xavier. Then Samantha admits that it can only be for one night because her family is in crisis. Despite the distance, though, neither of them can forget the time they spent together. More than 79,000 Goodreads users read it in May, and it has a 4.1 average rating.

#3:

The Tenant cover

The Tenant by Freida McFadden

McFadden has been a familiar name in this feature ever since The Housemaid exploded onto the bestseller lists. In her newest thriller, Blake and his fiancée rent out a room in their house to a new tenant. Soon, strange things start happening around the house, and the neighbors begin treating them differently. This one was read by almost 120,000 Goodreads users in May, and it has a 3.9 average rating.

#2:

sunrise on the reaping book cover

Sunrise on the Reaping (The Hunger Games #0.5) by Suzanne Collins

The Hunger Games series is still just as relevant (if not more so) than it was when it started more than 15 years ago. Collins’s latest, which tells Haymitch Abernathy’s story, also sold 1.5 million copies in English in its first week. It was read by 136,000 users in May and has a 4.6 average rating.

#1:

great big beautiful life book cover

Great Big Beautiful Life by Emily Henry

Emily Henry is a staple author on the bestseller lists and the Goodreads most read list, so it’s no surprise to see her newest title here. It follows two writers competing to write the official biography of a reclusive heiress. It was read by almost 164,000 users and has a 4.1 average rating.

If you’re looking for more buzzy books, check out The Bestselling Books of the Week, According to All the Lists.

Find more news and stories of interest from the book world in Breaking in Books.

Read Entire Article