Surprising Carson Beck Verdict Puts Mario Cristobal’s Costly Blunders Back into Unwanted Spotlight

In 2024, the Hurricanes were back—and back in a big way. Under Mario Cristobal, the Canes roared to a 10-3 finish, their first double-digit win season since 2017. Moreover, Cam Ward lit up the scoreboard, leading the nation’s top offense and becoming the No. 1 overall pick in the NFL Draft. But with Ward gone, Miami was staring at a massive void behind center. Enter Carson Beck. The former Georgia gunslinger hit the transfer portal and quickly became the hottest name available. Miami landed him—and with that, hopes soared. Now, the question is simple: Can Beck match Ward’s magic?

Look, Carson Beck’s numbers at Georgia were no joke—7,912 passing yards, and 58 TDs over 5 seasons. He was the heart of the Bulldogs’ offense and helped lead them to the CFP. But fate stepped in. A brutal injury in the SEC Game against Texas ended his season early. Now in Miami, Beck is on the comeback trail. And HC Mario Cristobal sees it all in a different light. “I think it’s great what he’s gone through because in the end we get the best version of Carson,” said Cristobal, during a Jacksonville Sports Radio appearance. Adding, “I think Carson, at the end of the day, had a million choices, and he chose to be at Miami.” The Canes aren’t just getting a QB—they’re getting a fired-up leader with unfinished business, per Cristobal.

However, not everyone views Miami’s rise through the same lens. Sure, Carson Beck brings elite talent, but the real test lies in how it’s used. On the May 19th episode of Josh Pate’s CFB Show, Pate highlighted the steady climb under Mario Cristobal. “There’s five wins the first year. Seven wins the second. 10 wins the third. If you just believe in linear progress, Miami is your program,” he said.

However, Pate also reminded fans how far the Canes have come, saying, “When he got there, they were a laughingstock… Now, you can’t have the College Football Playoff conversation without Miami in it.” So, the pieces are in place. But whether Beck leads them forward—or stalls in neutral—depends on what Cristobal and Co. do next.

Last year, Mario Cristobal had a rare opportunity in Cam Ward. The kind of talent coaches dream of. A true difference-maker. As Josh Pate put it, “You had him, just like LSU had Jayden Daniels two years ago. And you accomplished some good things, but you should have accomplished great things.” So, the Hurricanes had the firepower on offense, but something still held them back.

Then Pate didn’t hold back in his breakdown. “It’s on Mario. It’s on Lance Guidry, who’s not there anymore. It’s on players who don’t execute, it’s on players not being put in a position to execute by the coaching staff,” said Pate. So, like with Ward, if Cristobal can’t maximize Carson Beck’s potential this time, Miami’s title hopes could fall short again. However, the Hurricanes made moves to fix the flaws, starting with landing Beck out of the portal. Now, the hope is simple: Beck delivers, and this time, the defense doesn’t let them down.

Simply put, Cristobal had a golden opportunity to make a title run with Cam Ward—but he missed. Now, with Carson Beck at the helm, everything is on the line. This time, there’s no room for wasted potential. “But it’s got to be a lesson learned, because you can’t go back in time and change it. But I don’t think it’s too harsh to call that out,” said Pate.

Now, while Pate believes Cristobal has another shot this season, everything hinges on one question: Can Carson Beck replicate Cam Ward’s magic? If he can, Miami’s title hopes stay alive. If not, it could be another missed opportunity.

Carson Beck’s fate now lies in the hands of Mario Cristobal

Filling the shoes of Cam Ward won’t be easy for Miami’s new QB1, Carson Beck. The former Georgia star arrived in South Beach with big credentials, but Ward kept leveling up every year — and every transfer. Beck now faces a huge challenge: proving himself to Miami fans and, more importantly, to himself. An elbow injury and surgery cut his 2024 season short at Georgia, leaving plenty of questions—and high hopes—for what he can bring next.

Although the 22-year-old is still rehabbing from elbow surgery, fans got a glimpse of hope Friday when a video showed him throwing again—something he couldn’t do during spring practices. Here, On3’s J.D. Pickell raised a key question: Can Beck be “that guy” like Cam Ward? Pickell said, ” (Ward) walked in Day 1, you knew he was your starting quarterback, you knew he was the leader of your football team.” So Ward was the voice in the locker room, the go-to guy at halftime. But Beck missed spring reps, meaning he hasn’t had time to build that same bond or trust with his teammates. And that connection made all the difference.

While Pickell’s assessment might sound tough, he’s not counting Beck out. He simply points out the uphill climb Beck faces. Missing out on spring reps means building chemistry won’t come easily or fast. But that doesn’t mean it’s impossible. The door is still open — it just takes more time, more trust, and more work to reach that Cam Ward level of connection with the team.

The post Surprising Carson Beck Verdict Puts Mario Cristobal’s Costly Blunders Back into Unwanted Spotlight appeared first on EssentiallySports.