The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has revived a lawsuit against Lidl US, LLC, ruling that hourly employees must be compensated for time spent waiting to begin their shifts if they are required to be present by their employer. The decision, issued October 13, 2026, clarifies how federal labor law treats pre-shift waiting time when workers are under employer control but unable to perform their primary duties.
The case, Santos v. Lidl US, LLC (docket 25-2357), centers on allegations from former employee Sandra Santos. According to the complaint, Lidl required opening-shift employees to report to their stores 15 minutes before their scheduled start times. However, because managers were frequently late to arrive and the stores remained locked, employees were often forced to wait outside. Because the company’s time clocks were located inside the locked buildings, workers could not record this time as hours worked.
The distinction between 'engaged to wait' and 'waiting to be engaged' is critical for hourly pay compliance.
‘Engaged to Wait’ vs. ‘Waiting to be Engaged’
The legal core of the ruling rests on a regulatory distinction within the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The court distinguished between being “engaged to wait”—which is compensable work—and “waiting to be engaged,” which is generally not.
Under the FLSA, an employee is “engaged to wait” when the waiting time is spent primarily for the benefit of the employer and the employee is unable to use the time effectively for their own purposes. The 2nd Circuit panel, in a majority opinion by Judges Robinson and Rakoff, held that if an employer requires an employee to be at a specific location at a specific time, and the employee is prevented from working by circumstances beyond their control (such as being locked out), that time may constitute compensable work.
This contrasts with “waiting to be engaged,” such as a worker arriving early by choice to drink coffee or read the news before their shift starts. In such cases, the employee is not under the employer’s control and the time is not paid.
Reversing the Lower Court
The ruling reverses a previous decision by the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, which had dismissed the claims. The lower court originally viewed the waiting as a “preliminary activity” exempt from pay under the Portal-to-Portal Act. However, the appeals court found that the mandatory nature of the arrival time shifted the activity into the category of compensable employment.
The appeals court also addressed the “de minimis” defense—a legal doctrine where employers argue that very small increments of time (typically less than 10 or 15 minutes) are too trivial to track and pay. The 2nd Circuit declined to apply this defense at the motion-to-dismiss stage, noting that 15 minutes of unpaid time per week could accumulate into significant unpaid wages over time.
Judge Sullivan issued a dissenting opinion, reflecting a disagreement on whether the specific allegations met the threshold for “work” under the current statutory framework. However, the majority decision now serves as a binding precedent for federal courts within the 2nd Circuit, which covers New York, Connecticut, and Vermont.
For retail and hourly employers, the ruling suggests that mandatory early arrival policies must be paired with a functional way for employees to clock in immediately upon arrival. If workers are required to be on-site, the court’s analysis indicates they are likely entitled to pay, even if the store doors have not yet opened for business.
The post Lidl Lawsuit Revived Over Unpaid Waiting Time for Locked-Out Employees appeared first on World Weekly News.


Bengali (Bangladesh) ·
English (United States) ·