Carrie Underwood's Past As An American Idol Contestant Is Hurting Her Career As A Judge (Is She Too Sensitive?)

Carrie Underwood's turn as a judge on American Idol, the show that made her famous 20 years ago, has been praised by some as being the perfect role for her, and criticized by others, as her judging style has left some wanting more. Carrie was announced as a new judge in late 2024, replacing Katy Perry. Carrie's return was seen as a homecoming of sorts, the famous country star returns to the stage she once stood on, competing for the title of American Idol, to help guide young hopefuls in the entertainment industry.