American Idolseason 23 is finally coming to a close, and with just three competitors left in the mix, it's become clear that the finalists are disappointing after such a spectacular season of talented competitors. While American Idol season 23 has taken a lot of criticism for its newest judge, Carrie Underwood, throughout the season, there hasn't been as much by way of criticism for the contestants. Though the contestants on American Idol this season have shown tremendous talent throughout the competition, those who made the finals may not be the best of the best from the larger Idol group.