Aaron Judge Brutally Trolled by MLB Fans After Red Sox Villain Dominates in One-Sided Rivalry

You know the drill: Yankees and Red Sox. An intense rivalry that ignites an explosion every time they cross paths. And Friday night at Fenway Park was no exception. It exploded. Boston’s premier pitcher deployed his most formidable pitches—not against a typical batter, but against the MVP contender Aaron Judge.

This season, Judge is on fire with a .390 batting average, standing tall to add a third MVP title. And amidst that, what happened Friday was pure baseball theatre.

The moment Judge stepped on the plate, everyone was expecting sky-high homers. But the Red Sox had different plans. Forget the homers. Judge made a record that left everyone scratching their heads. Getting struck out 6 consecutive times.

It was Garrett Crochet, again, silencing Aaron Judge. The skid with Crochet has happened in two separate games this month. The first was on June 7, 2025, when Crochet struck out Judge three times at Yankee Stadium, which the Red Sox won 10–7. Then, just six days later, on June 13, 2025, at Fenway Park, Crochet struck out Judge again on a 98.2 mph fastball in their first game of the ongoing series. Six straight strikeouts for Crochet across two games.

And this time, the Red Sox again beat the Yankees 2-1.

The reactions? Fans can’t believe what they just saw. And the whispers quickly spread from the stands to the comment section.

GARRETT CROCHET STRIKES OUT AARON JUDGE FOR THE 6TH STRAIGHT TIME!

Just threw his two hardest pitches of the season at 99. pic.twitter.com/G2zWzWhefg

— Tyler Milliken (@tylermilliken_) June 14, 2025

Crochet kept his hold on the Fenway game itself. He struck out Judge three times in the 1st, 4th, and 6th innings, bringing more intensity on the diamond. Did Aaron Judge respond? Of course. A 443-foot-long response. It was his 26th home run this season, which came in the top of the 9th inning. Still, it was too late to stop Boston’s rally.

Even after adding Crochet, Walker Buehler, Alex Bregman, and Aroldis Chapman this offseason to compete for a World Series title, the Red Sox have struggled. They were fourth in the AL East with a 34-36 record entering Friday’s game. On the other side, the Yankees lead the division. But despite the club’s issues, Crochet has been a standout.

And now, his dominance over Judge has given Red Sox Nation something to brag about.

Fan reactions: The digital roast begins

The fact that Garrett Crochet keeps beating Aaron Judge has led to some very harsh but hilarious comments online.

One comment read, “Judge will be in Boston on Sunday to celebrate Father’s Day with his new Daddy.” This clever barb suggests that Crochet is now Judge’s new boss with his outstanding performance on the diamond. It was a brutal one-two blow because of the upcoming game on Sunday. And that’s Father’s Day, too.

Oct 28, 2024; New York, New York, USA; New York Yankees outfielder Aaron Judge (99) walks during the eighth inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers in game three of the 2024 MLB World Series at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Another fan follows up with a simple yet devastating joke. “Aaron, can you say ‘dada?'” The condescending tone makes Judge seem powerless against Crochet’s throwing, perfectly capturing the one-sided nature of their meetings.

A time to appreciate how fast Crochet’s pitches are, which is a sly shot at Judge’s inability to connect. “You mean he threw them past 99 at 99?” Garrett Crochet’s fastball was more than simply fast. It hit almost 99 mph, a searing beauty that left Aaron Judge and his famous No. 99 jersey motionless in the batter’s box for the sixth time.

A lack of faith and a little dissatisfaction at Aaron Judge’s surprising decline to Crochet. “Crazy how Judge went from mvp to Crochet’s personal highlight reel in one season .”  This remark aptly sums up the massive drop in Judge’s reputation when he faces off against Crochet. Someone just being compared with the great Babe Ruth and surpassing Mickey Mantle cannot hit! That shocks fans… 

The trolling continued, with a fan giving Judge’s performance versus Crochet a direct and honest review. “Crochet OWNS this low leverage bum.” Judge is a high-leverage player, but he gave up on this mound.

Crochet made a strong statement with an impressive performance. After those strikeouts, Judge fought back and hit a home run, but it was too late. Fans celebrated by turning the narrative of the Yankees’ superiority upside down. Well, no doubt, Sunday’s game will be more than just baseball.

It will be redemption vs. confidence, legacy vs. momentum. Are you excited?

The post Aaron Judge Brutally Trolled by MLB Fans After Red Sox Villain Dominates in One-Sided Rivalry appeared first on EssentiallySports.